Skip to main content

Before I Fall Movie VS Book

Image result for before I fall bookImage result for before I fall movie

Synopsis:
Samantha Kingston happens to be part of the popular crowd at her school. One day she wakes up and goes through her life like any other normal day. On this day though, she dies in a terrible car crash at the end of the night when leaving a party that goes wrong. Yet, the next morning she wakes up and everything is set back to that day again. Samantha realizes that even the smallest changes to that day have big impacts on herself, her family, her friends, and other people in her school. This goes on for a a couple of days, before Sam realizes that she must change something or be doomed to die and not repeat that same day over again.

Thoughts:
I didn't really love this novel, but I really liked the theme and message that Lauren Oliver way trying to convey to readers. I've read a lot of novels where the main characters are "mean girls" and they learn something that changes their lives, etc. This novel tries to reach young adults and show them that their decisions, how they speak, what they do or don't do really has an impact on their lives and the lives of others. The main character, Sam, gets to see other students outside her clique for the first time in her groundhog day-esque life, and it changes her perception of herself, her friends, and her life. This is what helps her finally make the decision which ends the repeating loop of that day for her.

Book VS Movie:
I read the book first in November of 2016, and then watched the movie when it was recently released in March of 2017. I thought the message of the book was really wonderful and very important for young adults to read and understand, but it wasn't a book that I really loved. I wondered how this would translate on to the big screen since I knew it was coming out as a movie.  First of all, I think that the movie was well-made and they chose very good actors and actresses for the various roles. Zoey Deutch, who plays Sam, did a fantastic job portraying Sam who is on the edge of her group of friends and fighting between her instinct to be popular and her instinct to change and understand why she is caught in this time loop. Another stand out was Logan Miller, who plays the lovesick Kent McFuller. Kent is a wonderful character that loves Sam even though she has become one of the "mean girls." He is sweet and kind and constantly trying to show Sam who she really is and who she really can be. Kent is the ultimate reason why Sam changes and is able to change the events leading to the time loop. I thought that the movie had a difficult time conveying the small subtle differences that her time loop days had on other side characters. It was hard to see those in the movie, whereas in the book you are able to delve much deeper into those side character and really see how her choices changed their lives. The book allows you to explore those intricacies that the movie with a time limit must skim over in order to focus on the bigger plot events and climax of the story. Overall, the movie stayed pretty close to the book with only minor differences in events. Both the book and movie were quite powerful and did very well in sales. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

So Lost...

For so long I have been focused on getting a full time job, and now that I have that I am once again focusing on my future. Questions just keep plaguing me like: "What am I going to be doing in a year?" "Will I go to grad school?" "Will I get a teaching job?" "Will I stay at my current job?" "Will I get another job somewhere?" And now I just can't seem to get these questions out of my head. I feel so lost.  I don't know what to do, where to apply, how to find new opportunities. Ever since I was a little kid, I have been striving for something. Whether it's doing well in sports each season, or getting good grades at the end of the year, getting Top 10 of my class, and then graduating high school, then it was doing well in college, finding a good major, and then graduating. Now that I am done with all that, I am finding that it's hard for me not to feel a little lost, lonely, confused, and without purpose. Once I discove...

Book # 38 Water for Elephants

Thanks to a co-worker who lent me the book, and friends and family that told me how amazing this book was, I finally read, Water for Elephants , by Sara Gruen. I have been hearing rave reviews from friends, family, coworkers, online sites, and other blogs about this book, and I have to say that I agree whole-heartedly. This is a wonderful book about love, life, the circus, and how connected people can become with each other and animals in such a short time. It's a stunning tale of the carnival and circus people of a time long ago, and how their lives revolved around the circus, the performers, the workmen, the animals, and the crowds. I loved all the characters in this book, and it was really interesting going from the past to the present with the main character. The love between Marlena and Jacob is so wonderful, and pure that it's a great part of this book. I also love how involved and invested Jacob becomes with the animals and some people in the circus. It's a tale of...

Book # 19

Today I had a day off, so I spent my day cleaning my apartment, listening to christmas music, catching up on shows, and the best of all, reading. I started and finished the 18th book, Something Like Fate  by Susane Colasanti. Another wonderful book from the warehouse book sale. This is by far my favorite of the three Colasanti books that I own, and have read recently. This is a book that really shows the reality of high school: the pressures, the people, the attitudes, the cruelty, the mocking, the relationships, and the hardness. I remember high school and how easy it was for someone to ruin another person's reputation with a few words that might not even be true. That's what happens in this book, Lani and Erin are best friends and then Erin starts dating Jason. Although, Jason and Lani are pretty much soul mates for high school anyways. The chaos ensues from there, and we see how relationships are built, torn down, and how reputations are ruined. This book also adds in fa...